Jess Pryles

‘Old Fashioned’ jelly with lemon, bourbon & bitters

old fashioned flavored jelly
Share this

This ‘Old Fashioned’ flavored jam is not too sweet, and has hints of bitters, maraschino, zesty lemon and a good boozy kick of bourbon.

This recipe comes with a teeny confession. Well actually, let’s call it a caveat.  There I was, sitting in a bar in Dallas with a friend, knocking back some fine sipping bourbon, which was a helluva way to spend a Friday afternoon. He was telling me about a canning company he planned on starting, and how someone had suggested an Old Fashioned jam, but that they didn’t know how they were going to come up with it.

“It’s easy!”, I exclaimed with bourbon-fuelled enthusiasm. “Lemon marmalade as base, spiked with bourbon and a hint of bitters. BOOM!”. And just like that, I had written the recipe. In the aftermath, my friend insisted I credit “server Jeremiah” with the concept, but I maintain that a food idea without a recipe is as useless as a microwaved steak. So technically, I still give myself full credit for this one.

lemon marmalade with bourbon and bitters

No matter whether you wanna give props to me or Jeremiah, and whether you prefer to all it jelly, jam or marmalade (it’s sort of a hybrid, actually) let’s all agree that this stuff is pretty delicious. There are lots of lemon marmalade recipes that mess around with muslin bags filled with pips and pith to create pectin, and others that require an overnight soaking of the lemons to remove bitterness. Good news, this is a faster and far less laborious version.

I discovered that adding a little extra splash of bourbon at the end will also make sure it’s a very “present” flavor, rather than cooking out during the simmering phase. Best of all, this recipe makes a fairly small amount of jam (about 12oz) so you don’t have to commit to having jars and jars of the stuff.

make your own bourbon jelly

old fashioned boozy jam jelly recipe with lemon

Print Recipe

'Old Fashioned' jelly with lemon, bourbon & bitters

Makes about 12 oz of jam. You will need a candy thermometer or similar to make sure you reach gelling temperature. I use and recommend Thermapen.

Ingredients

  • 4 large lemons
  • 2 cups white sugar
  • 3.5 cups water
  • 1/2 cup plus 1 tbsp bourbon
  • 6-8 dashes of bitters
  • 2 tsp maraschino cherry juice (optional)

Instructions

  1. Using three of the lemons, first zest them into a medium sized pot, then juice the remainder and set aside.

  2. Take the remaining lemon and slice in half lengthways. Then cut out the tough middle pith from each half in a V shaped notch. Slice each half thinly, then add to the pot.

  3. Add 1 cup of water to the pot and bring to the boil, then reduce heat and simmer for 10 minutes. Discard water by pouring through a fine meshed strainer.

  4. Return the lemons and zest back to the pot, and add another cup of water. Repeat the process, simmering for another 10 minutes, then straining again.

  5. For a final time, return the lemon and zest to the pot. Add 1.5 cups water, 0.5 cups bourbon, and the sugar. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat once more to an active simmer. Reduce until the mixture thickens and reaches exactly 220f.

  6. Once at temperature, remove from heat and stir in the maraschino juice, tbsp of bourbon and bitters. Allow to cool 10-15 minutes, then fill a clean airtight jar with the marmalade mix. Store in the fridge for up to 10 days.

By Jess Pryles

Jess Pryles is a full fledged Hardcore Carnivore. She’s a cook, writer, and TV personality specializing in red meat, with penchant for grilling and bourbon. She's also a respected authority on Texas & competition style barbecue. Born in Australia, she now resides in Austin, Texas.

Want to request a recipe?